As a digital subscriber, you’ll receive unlimited access to Horn Book web exclusives and extensive archives, as well as access to our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database.
To access other site content, visit The Horn Book homepage.
To continue you need an active subscription to hbook.com.
Subscribe now to gain immediate access to everything hbook.com has to offer, as well as our highly searchable Guide/Reviews Database, which contains tens of thousands of short, critical reviews of books published in the United States for young people.
Thank you for registering. To have the latest stories delivered to your inbox, select as many free newsletters as you like below.
No thanks. Return to article
480 pp.
| Candlewick |
October, 2025 |
TradeISBN 9781536230505$18.99
(1)
4-6
Twelve-year-old Peter Huckaby-Green's life changes when the Tinkerers arrive in his close-knit town of Stargazers Valley. Peter directs the two astromancers to his parents' inn and agrees to help with their research into starstuff, a magical substance left by the Southern Skeins (think aurora borealis) on the town's mountaintops, but just why Peter calls this his "third-worst mistake" is left to the story to reveal. Carlson's tapestry of narratives obscures the question initially, between school drama with Peter's iconoclastic best friend; family and inn shenanigans (mysterious guests, disruptive twin sisters); and revelations about the fascist police state used to control starstuff and everything else. Excerpts from police interviews and transcripts of surveillance footage from the inn advance the story, along with folkloric "star tales," but once Peter investigates the heavy chest the Tinkerers brought to the inn and readers surmise how that relates to repeated five-second gaps in the video monitors, developments begin to fly thick and fast. The ideas around time travel, do-overs, and responsibility are refreshingly relatable, and the story, whose every character is distinctly and humorously drawn, comes together in a brilliant synthesis of plot, theme, and good-natured chaos.
Reviewer: Anita L. Burkam
| Horn Book Magazine Issue:
November, 2025